New to Fort Collins?
Here’s how to find a gym that actually fits your life.
If you’ve just moved to Fort Collins or you’re looking for a gym that actually feels like a good fit, you’re in the right place. Whether you’re switching from another gym, new to town, or starting your fitness journey for the first time, finding the best Fort Collins gym for your goals can feel overwhelming.
There are a lot of options in town, but not all gyms are created equal. Here are a few things to think about as you explore, and why OTAC (Old Town Athletic Club) might be exactly what you’re looking for. If you’re still getting to know the city, check out things to do in Fort Collins while you settle in.
1. What Are Your Fitness Goals? (And How Your Gym Should Support Them)
Before you even tour a gym, it helps to get clear on what you’re looking for.
Are you hoping to:
- Build strength?
- Stay consistent with movement?
- Train for an event like HYROX or a local 5K?
- Find a community to help keep you accountable?
Different gyms offer different approaches. Some give you 24-hour access to machines but no guidance. Others only offer a few class formats.
At OTAC, we blend structure and flexibility. You’ll get group classes like CrossFit and HYROX, plus 24/7 open gym access — everything you’d want from a Fort Collins gym that’s actually built around your schedule.
2. Pay attention to the people and the vibe
You could walk into the nicest facility in town, but if the energy feels off, you probably won’t stick around. The right gym should feel welcoming and supportive, even on your hardest days.
At OTAC, our members range from first-time lifters to retirees to people preparing for their first competition. What connects them is the desire to grow and be part of a real community.
New members often tell us they were nervous to walk in the door. A few weeks later, they’re high-fiving people after class and looking forward to the next one.
3. Check the fine print — or lack of it
Let’s be honest. Nobody wants to get locked into a long-term contract with hidden fees.
Here’s what you won’t find at OTAC:
- Long-term contracts
- Hidden fees
- Confusing sign-up processes
We’re locally owned and community-driven. We list our pricing clearly on our website and offer month-to-month memberships. That means we actually know your name, and we’re not here to upsell you into something that doesn’t make sense.
4. Make consistency convenient
The biggest key to progress is showing up. If your gym isn’t easy to get to or doesn’t work with your schedule, it’s going to be harder to stay consistent.
We’re located just northwest of The Lyric in Fort Collins, with bike trail access that brings you right to our front door.
We also offer 24/7 open gym access, so you can train early, late, or whenever your schedule allows. No waiting for someone to unlock the doors.
5. Try before you commit
The best way to know if a gym is right for you? Come check it out.
At OTAC, we offer:
- Free intro classes
- “Bring a Friend” weeks (like the one happening July 27th – August 2nd)
- Drop-in class options
- Free Gym Only Trials
- Free Hyrox Trial
- Free CrossFit Trial
You’ll get to experience the coaching, the workouts, and the atmosphere. Without needing to make a decision on the spot. We want it to be the right fit for you.
OTAC: A Fort Collins Gym That Feels Like Home
You don’t have to be in the best shape of your life to start. You just have to be ready to walk through the door.
If you’re searching for a gym in Fort Collins that’s welcoming, locally owned, and focused on long-term results, we’d love to meet you.
